Best-Reviewed Plays
| Zero Hour | A | |
| Our Town | A | |
| Wife to James Whelan | A | |
| The Flying Karamazov Brothers: 4Play | A- | |
| Freud's Last Session | A- |
Best-Reviewed Musicals
| Avenue Q | A | |
| The Lion King | A | |
| Chicago | A | |
| Fela! | A- | |
| Billy Elliot | A- |
Family Fare
| The Lion King | A | |
| Our Town | A | |
| Billy Elliot | A- | |
| The Flying Karamazov Brothers: 4Play | A- | |
| The Phantom of the Opera | B |
Stars on Stage
| La Cage aux Folles | A- | |
| A Little Night Music | B+ | |
| Long Story Short | B+ | |
| In The Heights | B+ | |
| Rock of Ages | B |
Brand New
| It Must Be Him | D- | |
| An Error of the Moon | D+ | |
| Wife to James Whelan | A | |
| Power Balladz | C+ | |
| Long Story Short | B+ |
Last Chance
| Long Story Short | B+ | |
| Secrets of the Trade | B | |
| The Screwtape Letters | B+ | |
| The Irish...and How They Got That Way | B | |
| Come Fly Away | B |