Best-Reviewed Plays
| Traces | A |
|
| Sleep No More | A |
|
| War Horse | A |
|
| Other Desert Cities | A- |
|
| Love, Loss, and What I Wore | A- |
|
Best-Reviewed Musicals
| Avenue Q | A |
|
| Chicago | A |
|
| The Book of Mormon | A |
|
| The Lion King | A |
|
| Silence! The Musical | A- |
|
People's Choice
| Sleep No More | A |
|
| The Book of Mormon | A |
|
| Freud's Last Session | A |
|
| The Devil's Music: The Life and Blues of Bessie Smith | A |
|
| Jersey Boys | A |
|
Family Fare
| War Horse | A |
|
| The Lion King | A |
|
| The Phantom of the Opera | B |
|
| Mary Poppins | C+ |
|
| Wicked | C+ |
|
Stars on Stage
| Other Desert Cities | A- |
|
| Anything Goes | A- |
|
| Seminar | B+ |
|
| Richard III | B+ |
|
| The Gershwins' Porgy and Bess | B+ |
|
Under $50
| Traces | A |
|
| Silence! The Musical | A- |
|
| The Devil's Music: The Life and Blues of Bessie Smith | B+ |
|
| Chinglish | B+ |
|
| Richard III | B+ |
|
Brand New
| The Road to Mecca | B |
|
| The Gershwins' Porgy and Bess | B+ |
|
| Richard III | B+ |
|
| Outside People | B |
|
| How the World Began | B- |
|
Last Chance
| Million Dollar Quartet (Broadway) | B |
|
| Chinglish | B+ |
|
| Outside People | B |
|
| How the World Began | B- |
|
| Relatively Speaking | C |
|
